Why Not: The Two Words That Unlock Bold Leadership
Commercial break: if you have a few moments, I want to hear from you. Click the link at the end of this post, and let me know what topics and content you want to hear about in future posts. I'll do a random draw for a free ebook from Brene Brown on bold courageous leadership called Daring Greatly.
_______________________________
What if the most powerful question you could ask as a leader isn’t “Why?” but “Why not?”
From Justifying to Possibility Thinking
In healthcare, government, and nonprofits, leaders are often trained to justify every move. Why is this important? Why should we do it this way? These questions serve a purpose—they help ensure accountability and strategy. But sometimes, the biggest breakthroughs don’t come from asking “Why?” They come when we pause, step back, and ask, “Why not?”
“Why not?” flips the narrative. Instead of narrowing the focus on risks or barriers, it invites exploration and opens the door to possibility. Adam Grant, organizational psychologist and author of Think Again, emphasizes the importance of “rethinking” in leadership: “The joy of being wrong is the freedom to keep learning.” Asking “Why not?” helps leaders embrace curiosity over perfection, creating space for bold ideas and fresh solutions.
My Own ‘Why Not?’ Moment
This question has driven real change in my leadership. When launching a major initiative, it was easy to get stuck in “Why?” Why now? Why this? Why me? The barriers felt real—limited resources, competing priorities, and fear of failure.
But then I reframed the question: “Why not?” Why not now? Why not try? Why not take one step toward the vision? Suddenly, the path forward felt less intimidating. Instead of focusing on the challenges, I saw the possibilities—the lives we could impact, the systems we could improve, the momentum we could build.
Leaders like Brené Brown remind us that stepping into the unknown isn’t about being fearless—it’s about choosing courage even when fear is present. Asking “Why not?” isn’t about ignoring risks; it’s about deciding that the potential impact is worth stepping forward.
How “Why Not?” Sparks Change
If you’ve ever hesitated on a decision or felt stuck, asking “Why not?” can be the shift that moves you forward. Here’s how to use this question to overcome hesitation and spark change:
1. Challenge Assumptions
Ask yourself: What’s stopping me from moving forward? Are those obstacles as solid as they seem, or are they rooted in fear? Simon Sinek, author of Start With Why, says, “The only way to truly overcome our challenges is by starting with clarity of purpose.” Asking “Why not?” forces a reevaluation of barriers and sparks creative solutions.
2. Focus on the Upside
Often, we’re so busy preparing for worst-case scenarios that we forget to consider the best-case outcomes. What could happen if this works? What impact could you make? Marcus Buckingham, a thought leader in strengths-based leadership, advises, “Discover what you do well and do more of it.” Asking “Why not?” lets you focus on the possibilities instead of just the risks.
3. Take Small Action
Big changes start with small steps. Break your bold idea into manageable pieces. As James Clear, author of Atomic Habits, puts it: “Success is the product of daily habits—not once-in-a-lifetime transformations.” The smallest action toward your goal can build momentum and confidence. I call this the “O.N.E. thing” approach to moving forward which I wrote about in an earlier post.
Now Take a Moment
Think about your leadership journey:
• What’s one bold idea you’ve been holding back on?
• What’s stopping you from acting?
• What’s one small step you could take today to explore the possibility?
These questions aren’t about finding the perfect answer—they’re about starting the conversation with yourself. When I first started as a leader, I thought I had to wait till something was perfect.
And I held on to that idea for a long while. And held onto it, even for a moment longer, waiting for everything to be just right. And then I missed opportunities. Or I watched things in the industry continue to be status quo at the cost to clinicians and citizens. To be honest, I kicked myself for being overly cautious.
After missing these opportunities, I realized that maybe perfect wasn’t the goal, but rather “good enough” was. I also realized that I held myself back from asking “Why not”. It was me, not the idea, that was in the pause. So after an honest (yet kind) conversation with myself, and maybe a few trusted allies, I knew I had to start letting go of the fear and the need for perfection. And get more comfortable, with a more incremental or baby-step approach to kicking off a bold idea. It allowed me to be bold but not feel like I had to climb the whole mountain in 1 day.
What I learned over these years is that your curiosity is your superpower. Curiosity combined with passion, is a massive superpower. Asking “Why not?” is the key to unlocking it. So let’s nurture it, and nurture that little voice, that keeps telling you, ”I think this is a good idea”.
Final Thoughts: “Why Not?” Is a Mindset Shift
Imposter syndrome, fear of failure, and perfectionism are challenges every leader faces—especially when stepping into bold new ideas. But bold leadership isn’t about having all the answers. It’s about asking the right questions and taking the first step.
When you ask “Why not?” you shift your focus from barriers to possibilities, from hesitation to action. You don’t have to have it all figured out—just start.
So, what’s one thing you can ask “Why not?” about this week? Share your reflections and bold ideas with people you trust. Set those great ideas free. Start a conversation and
Leave a spark wherever you go.
Keep SHiNEing.
PS. I love hearing from all of you and making sure I am writing about the things that matter the most to you, regarding being a true-to-you, heart-centred, changemaker. If you have ideas, would you take 5 minutes and share your ideas!!!
https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/27CRSHM
Email: SHiNE_Workbook@shaw.ca
Unsubscribe · Preferences